Buying an Education: Our First Boat, Tiki
A $14,000 Catalina 34, a complete refit, and two very big educations. Kelly looks back at the boat that started it all.

Before there was Neverland, there was Tiki, our Catalina 34. We bought her in 2017 after she'd been sitting for three years. She was old, sad, and neglected, so we offered a whopping $14,000, and she was ours.
She needed a complete refit. We knew we weren't just buying a boat. We were buying an education. As it turned out, we bought two: one for each of us.
“She's going to sink any minute”
I'll be honest: I was convinced she was going to sink any minute. I made sure I knew exactly where the bungs were and how to use them, just in case. (Bungs are the tapered wooden plugs you hammer into a hole if a fitting below the waterline ever fails.)
She never did sink. In fact, she turned out to be a great first boat. But first, there was a lot of work to do.
The refit
The cabin floors were half rotted out, so we replaced them with new teak and holly panels. The running rigging was more moss than rope. That had to go, too.
Then we investigated the freshwater system and decided it was beyond saving. At that point, anything we did couldn't make it any worse. It got a complete overhaul.

The worst jobs, by far, were replacing all the windows and replacing the holding tank and blackwater hoses. I learned the hard way that just touching those old hoses left a sticky substance on my hands and a smell that lingered for days. I'll leave the rest to your imagination.
And that was only part of the list. There were also:
- All new cushions
- A new dodger and bimini
- A new mainsail
- New hatches
- Moving the propane tank
- Removing all the teak and plugging hundreds of holes
- Painting the topside gelcoat and the nonskid decking
I spent a week repainting the deck. Of everything we did, that was probably Tiki's biggest glow-up. There was finally a point when you could look at her and see the boat we were working toward, rather than another list of things to fix.


Somewhere along the way, I also learned to sew! I made the curtains, the rope bags and the hatch covers myself.
Exploring the Chesapeake
Once she was sailing, we took her to Cambridge, Oxford and St. Michaels. We made a few visits to Herrington Harbour South, took friends out with us, and started enjoying the boat we'd put so much work into.
The night it poured, and the morning he proposed
Our trip to St. Michaels is the one I'll never forget. The night before, we anchored out on Tiki for the very first time, and it poured all night. That wasn't great with a giant crack in one of the windows. Tom slept great. I finally got to bed around 2 a.m.
The next morning, Tom surprised me: he'd booked us a slip at the Inn at Perry Cabin. It was awesome pulling up to the inn on our own boat, and we handled all the lines ourselves. Then he proposed, right in front of the water. It was August 1, 2018, the day before my birthday.

Lemon's first birthday

Tiki was part of our family's milestones right to the end. On October 23, 2020, we celebrated Lemon's first birthday on board, party hat and all.
Letting her go
We sold Tiki in November 2020. We knew we'd be PCSing (making a military move) the next summer, so we planned ahead. We knew she'd go fast because she looked and ran great, and she did: she was only on the market for about two weeks.
I was not ready.
The man who bought her was planning to take her to the Bahamas right after the purchase. We loved the idea of Tiki doing what she was meant to do and heading south. We still keep in touch now and then. Later, he sent us photos as he sailed her past New York on his way to the Naval War College, where he'd be keeping her.
We'd bought an old, neglected tub. Two very big educations later, we sold a seaworthy yacht full of new life and ready to explore. She'd taught us how to fix things, how much we could do ourselves, and what it felt like to arrive somewhere on our own boat.
It would be pretty awesome to come across Tiki somewhere warm, with Neverland.